Preserving the Preservers: Internet Archive Staff Launch Union Drive Amid a Turbulent Era for Digital Heritage

Share
Preserving the Preservers: Internet Archive Staff Launch Union Drive Amid a Turbulent Era for Digital Heritage

Executive Overview

In a watershed moment for the digital preservation movement, employees of the Internet Archive—the beloved San Francisco-based nonprofit best known for housing the ubiquitous Wayback Machine—have officially announced their campaign to unionize. More than 80 of the 124 eligible United States-based workers have signed cards to affiliate with the Communications Workers of America (CWA), marking a profound shift in labor dynamics within the cultural heritage and digital archiving sectors.

The organizing committee has formally requested that Internet Archive founder and digital pioneer Brewster Kahle voluntarily recognize the union. Simultaneously, to ensure that their legal bases are covered should management resist, organizers have filed a petition for a formal union election with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).

Far from demanding radical overhauls, the platform of the Internet Archive Union is grounded in practical, stabilizing measures: competitive and equitable wages, universal benefits that apply across all tiers of staff, and transparent pathways for career advancement and professional promotion. Danielle Leard, a member of the worker organizing committee, connected the internal push for better workplace conditions directly to the institution’s core mission. According to Leard, establishing job security, comprehensive health and welfare benefits, and livable wages are not peripheral demands; rather, they go hand-in-hand with ensuring the long-term survival and sustainability of the Archive itself.

This labor mobilization arrives during a uniquely volatile chapter in the Internet Archive’s history. Over the past several years, the organization has weathered severe legal setbacks, devastating cyberattacks, shifting technological landscapes characterized by the explosive growth of generative artificial intelligence, and, conversely, prestigious federal recognition. By examining the unionization effort against this multifaceted backdrop, it becomes clear that the workforce’s push for a collective voice is both a reaction to modern institutional pressures and a proactive step to secure the future of the internet’s memory bank.


Detailed Chronology of the Organizing Campaign

The public rollout of the Internet Archive Union did not happen in a vacuum; it is the culmination of months of quiet, careful foundational work by employees navigating a rapidly evolving workplace. While digital technology non-profits have historically prided themselves on mission-driven workplace cultures—where passion for the cause sometimes substitutes for competitive compensation—staff members increasingly recognize that structural protections are necessary.

The Buildup and Card-Signing Drive

For months, employees across various departments—from software engineers maintaining the complex infrastructure of the Wayback Machine to librarians, digitizers, and administrative personnel—began discussing workplace concerns behind closed doors. Issues surrounding wage stagnation amidst high living costs in the San Francisco Bay Area, coupled with a lack of standardized promotion tracks, served as early catalysts for discontent.

As momentum grew, organizers partnered with the Communications Workers of America (CWA), a union with an increasingly robust portfolio representing tech and media workers. By the time the campaign went public, over 65% of the 124 eligible U.S. workers had signed union authorization cards. This decisive threshold demonstrates a solid mandate from the floor up, providing the organizing committee with substantial leverage as they approach leadership.

The Approach to Leadership and NLRB Filing

Following the successful card-signing drive, the union formally reached out to founder Brewster Kahle, asking him to voluntarily recognize the bargaining unit. Voluntary recognition allows employers to bypass the often adversarial, drawn-out processes of a contested NLRB election, signaling a collaborative relationship between executive leadership and the workforce.

However, acknowledging the realities of modern corporate and non-profit labor relations, the workers did not rely solely on a voluntary request. Alongside their letter to Kahle, the organizing committee filed an official election petition with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). This dual-track approach ensures that if management drags its feet or refuses to recognize the union voluntarily, the legal machinery is already in motion to force a democratic election. As of publication, Brewster Kahle and the Internet Archive’s executive leadership have not issued a formal public response to the union drive.


Supporting Context & Metrics: The Bay Area Precedent and Industry Trends

The Internet Archive’s unionization campaign does not exist in a vacuum; it is part of a broader wave of organizing sweeping through Silicon Valley, non-profit institutions, and cultural organizations.

The Wikimedia Foundation Precedent

To understand the potential trajectory of the Internet Archive’s campaign, one needs only look a few miles down the road at another major Bay Area tech non-profit: the Wikimedia Foundation.

In September, U.S. staff members at the Wikimedia Foundation successfully unionized with the CWA. However, that victory was hard-fought. The Wikimedia Foundation initially declined to voluntarily recognize the union, forcing the staff to take the matter to a formal NLRB vote. Despite the friction of a contested process, Wikimedia workers demonstrated overwhelming solidarity, voting in favor of unionization by a landslide count of 158 to 14.

This recent precedent establishes a clear playbook for non-profit digital heritage workers. It proves that even organizations founded on open-source ideals and public stewardship are not automatically immune to traditional labor friction, but it also demonstrates that worker solidarity can decisively carry the day through an NLRB election if voluntary recognition is denied.

Inside the Numbers: Demographics and Demands

  • Bargaining Unit Size: 124 eligible U.S. workers.
  • Initial Support: Over 80 workers signed cards immediately, representing a robust supermajority of roughly 65%.
  • Core Demands:
    • Competitive, cost-of-living-adjusted pay scales to combat inflation and Bay Area expenses.
    • Equitable, universal benefits that cover all employees uniformly.
    • Transparent career development frameworks and objective pathways to promotions.

These figures illustrate that the workers are not operating out of transient grievances, but are seeking structural reforms designed to curb high turnover and retain institutional knowledge—an asset of paramount importance for an archive housing petabytes of human history.


The Internet Archive’s Rocky Recent History

To fully grasp the timing of this labor campaign, one must examine the extraordinary pressures the Internet Archive has faced over the last several years. The institution has transitioned from a beloved, quietly operating digital library into a frequent target of high-stakes legal battles, malicious cyberattacks, and systemic technological shifts.

The Legal Front: Copyright and E-Book Lending

In 2023, the Internet Archive suffered a major legal blow when a federal judge ruled against the organization in a lawsuit brought by major publishing houses (including Hachette, HarperCollins, John Wiley & Sons, and Penguin Random House). The publishers sued over the Archive’s "Open Library" and its Emergency Library program, which lent scanned digital copies of physical books.

The Internet Archive's workers are unionizing

The court ruled that this digital lending model violated traditional publisher copyrights, rejecting the Archive’s fair use defense. The decision forced the institution to curtail significant portions of its digital book lending operations, creating financial uncertainty and altering a core service relied upon by researchers, students, and the general public.

Infrastructure Under Siege: The 2024 Cyberattacks

Compounding its legal woes, the Internet Archive experienced catastrophic cybersecurity incidents in late 2024. The platform was targeted by massive Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDoS) attacks accompanied by data breaches that compromised user credentials and defaced the website with pop-up messages.

These attacks knocked the Wayback Machine—the cornerstone of the organization’s public utility—offline for weeks. For the engineers, system administrators, and support staff, this meant working around the clock under immense pressure to restore core infrastructure, secure compromised databases, and defend against ongoing malicious traffic. The operational strain of these cyberattacks underscored the critical, frontline nature of the Archive’s technical staff.

The AI Backlash and Crawler Blocks

As if copyright litigation and cyberattacks were not enough, the rapid ascent of generative artificial intelligence introduced a new operational crisis. Throughout 2024 and 2025, numerous media outlets, publishers, and website operators began aggressively blocking the Internet Archive’s web-crawling bots.

Fearing that AI companies would exploit the Archive’s historical snapshots as a backdoor workaround to scrape copyrighted text, images, and data without permission or compensation, site owners slammed their digital doors. This wave of blocks threatened the very completeness of the historical record the Archive was built to capture. Navigating this hostile web ecosystem required intense diplomatic, technical, and legal maneuvering by Archive leadership and staff.

A Beacon of Hope: Federal Recognition

Amidst this cascade of crises, the Internet Archive achieved a historic milestone in 2025: the United States Senate officially designated the Internet Archive as an official U.S. government document depository.

This designation formally integrated the Archive into the federal framework for preserving public records, elevating its status from a private non-profit initiative to an officially recognized pillar of government information preservation. While this recognition validated the immense cultural and civic value of the institution, it also highlighted the paradox at the heart of the organization: an entity trusted by the federal government to preserve history was simultaneously struggling internally with staff compensation, benefit consistency, and career pathways.


Official Statements and Stakeholder Perspectives

The public narrative surrounding the Internet Archive Union campaign highlights a fascinating interplay between institutional mission and labor rights.

The Workforce Perspective

Organizers have been careful to frame their union campaign not as an adversarial challenge to Brewster Kahle’s vision, but as a mechanism to protect it. Danielle Leard’s commentary cuts to the heart of this philosophy:

"Job security, comprehensive benefits, and livable wages go hand-in-hand with sustaining the Archive long-term."

By tying their working conditions directly to the longevity of the institution, employees are asserting that burnout, high turnover, and financial stress among staff pose a direct threat to the Archive’s stability. If talented engineers, archivists, and catalogers cannot afford to live in the Bay Area or build a sustainable career at the non-profit, the quality and continuity of the preservation work inevitably suffer.

Management’s Silence

As of this writing, founder Brewster Kahle and the Internet Archive executive team have maintained silence regarding the union drive. Historically, Kahle has championed open access, free information, and progressive ideals. How management responds to the CWA organizing drive will serve as a litmus test for whether these organizational values extend inward to the treatment of its own workforce.

Labor advocates will be watching closely to see if management chooses the cooperative route of voluntary recognition—similar to how progressive tech organizations ideally operate—or if they contest the election through anti-union consultants, risking the public relations fallout that plagued the Wikimedia Foundation before its eventual worker victory.


Future Outlook: What Lies Ahead for the Internet Archive

The unionization push at the Internet Archive represents a critical inflection point not just for the organization, but for the broader digital heritage sector. As cultural institutions face unprecedented pressures from artificial intelligence, shifting legal paradigms, and economic instability, the role of labor within these spaces is being radically reassessed.

Short-Term Scenarios

  1. Voluntary Recognition: Brewster Kahle and the executive board could surprise observers by accepting the union cards, stepping forward to negotiate a collective bargaining agreement in good faith. This would avoid a costly, divisive campaign and allow the institution to focus its resources on its core mission and ongoing legal battles.
  2. NLRB Election Battle: If management opts against voluntary recognition, the process will move to a formal NLRB election. Given the strong initial supermajority (over 80 out of 124 workers signed cards), union advocates enter the contest with a distinct numerical advantage. However, a contested election period often introduces friction, internal tension, and external scrutiny that a non-profit weathering multiple crises can ill afford.

Long-Term Implications for Digital Preservation

Ultimately, the outcome of this organizing drive will ripple across the tech non-profit landscape. Cultural heritage institutions have long relied on the passion of their workers, occasionally exploiting that devotion to justify below-market wages or precarious employment structures.

If the Internet Archive Union succeeds in securing fair wages, universal benefits, and structured career paths, it will set a powerful precedent. It will demonstrate that safeguarding the history of the internet cannot be decoupled from safeguarding the livelihoods of the people who do the preserving. As the Archive steps into its new role as an official U.S. government document depository while continuing to battle copyright challenges and AI-era scraping blocks, a unionized, stable, and empowered workforce may prove to be its greatest asset for survival in the decades to come.

Did you find this story helpful?

Share it with your friends and colleagues on social media.

Share